IS IT AMI OR TAIGA!?

Taiga: Eh~? Baka-chi tsundere?
I get the feeling you want to leave now…well, it’s ok. Following this is just a nonsense ramble on my part on why I think Ami is more of a tsundere than Taiga. This, I guess, is blasphemy to the Taiga crowd…or tsundere lovers in general…>_>
If you’ve seen enough anime, chances are that you’ve come upon the term “tsundere”…if not…watch more anime. But in a nut shell, a tsundere character is a moody combative character who hides his/her true feelings from everyone else…more so to the person of interest. But recently, this term seems to have been broadened and applied to any character who blushes profoundly and/or to characters who deny whatever made her/him blush…be it a comment about what the person likes…a la Kagami…or about the person he/she likes…just about any character in a romantic/harem anime.
In Toradora! the person labeled “tsundere” is Aisaka Taiga, it’s been carved in stone and no one will question it. But Taiga, is one of those character labeled a tsundere because of her blushing face and her rough character. She puts up a strong front saying that she’s shouldn’t be taken lightly. But behind that though exterior, is a small loli girl wanting some love and a girl whose a lot nicer than appears.
Is that’s really tsundere? Um…yeah, to an extent.
Well, she bad mouths/abuses Ryuuji any chance she gets, that’s the “tsun” part. But when alone or when Ryuuji does something for her…she shows signs of kindness…that’s the “dere” part. So by definition, she’s tsundere.
But isn’t “dere” the part of the character that has affection…in terms of love, not appreciation…towards the lead?
We gotta remember that Taiga herself has said plenty times that she likes Kitamura. Going dere dere {bashful and lovestruck} in front of him every single time. She’s dere dere to Kitamura, but tsun tsun {rough and violent} to Ryuuji…Isn’t tsundere supposed to be tsun tsun and dere dere to the same person?
You can say that she’s dere dere for Ryuuji because she screamed “RYUUJI IS MINE!!!”…later rebutting with “Yeah, Ryuuji is my dog!”…becoming tsun tsun. But wasn’t she just pissed off because no one came to Ryuuji’s aid because everyone was trying to get a look at Ami? She was just pissed and didn’t want anyone to get near him…probably thinking no one has the right to help him now that she alone brought him out of the pool. I’m not too really sure she has dere dere feelings for Ryuuji…
But no matter what I say, everyone has already labeled her tsundere…for Ryuuji…and I to would say she is {to an extent} a tsundere character. But the tsundere of Toradora!, I think, is Ami.
Ami too has all the qualities of a tsundere and is more true to the {real} definition than Taiga is. Initially, you wouldn’t know a tsundere character at first sight of them. The realization that the character is in fact tsundere is supposed to be revealed to you when said character either starts feeling love for the lead and is unable to properly voice her feelings…be it by being unable to voice them or by having an external force stopping her from doing so. Case in point, Kawashima Ami.
Our initial reaction to her was not a good one. She came across as a conceited b!tch who is waaay too in love with her self…and she was in fact just that. But as the series progressed and she got to be influenced by Taiga and Ryuuji…just like Kitamura wanted…her real self started coming out.
Since her appearance, she has been ‘playing around’ with Ryuuji…an effort just to make Taiga mad…or at least that’s what people concluded. But maybe she was playing around Ryuuji because she has feelings for him. She can’t really show her true emotions, so maybe she put up that playful mask to try to get near him? Tsundere quality? I would say so. Her playing around with him is the same as putting up a strong front…you can say it’s reverse psychology. By acting like she is just playing and teasing him, you can say she’s putting up a front to hide her feelings…which she is not able to properly convey.
Ami doesn’t seem to open up to anyone…not even to her childhood friend Kitamura. But around Ryuuji, she seems more herself and is more prone to releasing her true nature. So far, she has only talked to Ryuuji about things she hides from everyone else…like the stalker thing.
Originally, she would put up a strong front and act as if it doesn’t bother her…the tsun part. But when she was alone with Ryuuji and the stalker appeared…she just couldn’t hold up that front anymore and opened up to him, telling him the story and what she was feeling…not really dere, but close to it. She was more dere in the cave. There, she tried to voice her feelings…her feeling for Ryuuji…but her ‘chance’ was shunned with the screams of Minori.
Ami may not blush as much as Taiga, but I think that she is more tsundere than Taiga is. Her “fake” mask is her strong exterior, her “playful” mask is another front, but when alone with Ryuuji, she’s more of herself and can’t voice what she wants to say, unless she dons one of those masks…leading Ryuuji to misinterpret her words…
*sigh* I really don’t why I made this nonsense post, no matter what I say people will say Ami IS NOT of tsundere quality…they’ll give it to Taiga. But as I was watching that scene in the cave, I couldn’t help but think of this…and the urge to voice it just grew the longer I thought about it. I’ll get rebutted, but I’ll just say with confidence that AMI IS IN FACT MORE TSUNDERE THAN TAIGA!

Palmtop Tiger VS Fake Chihuahua
CHIHUAHUA WINS!




tl;dr
Isn’t a real tsundere one that it’s initially very combative and hostile but her feelings gradually change throughout the eroge, VN, anime, or manga? Or in Toradora!’s case, maybe light novels.
By: IcyStorm on December 6, 2008
at 12:22 pm
@IcyStorm: Yes, that’s what a tsundere is. Which is why I say Ami is tsundere. Her feelings have gradually changed, she had no interest in Ryuuji in the beginning, but now she does…and hides those feelings behind that “playful” uninterested mask of hers.
And like I said, she brings the dere when alone with Ryuuji…
By: 53RG10 on December 6, 2008
at 12:50 pm
That snowflake effect is maxing out my 2GHz processor… P4in.
By: Toiski on December 6, 2008
at 2:14 pm
One thing the anime isn’t doing well is showing the gradual softening towards Ryuuji by Taiga… which makes the flip-flopping on camera more like the current definition of tsundere (aka: Kugimiya Rie roles) instead of the more classic ‘melting into dere’ mode… which is what Ami is starting to do.
By: Haesslich on December 6, 2008
at 9:32 pm
I pretty much agree with you.
By: Keriaku on December 8, 2008
at 5:18 am
“a small loli girl wanting some love”
and that is why Taiga wins in my book
By: the monster on December 12, 2008
at 3:27 pm
anyways, I think Ami seems to be more of a Yandere.
By: .. on March 13, 2009
at 5:28 pm
ps esta serie me encanta ps sobre todo x la trama tan divertida k lastima k solo fueron 25 capitulos merecian mas………
By: shvo on March 27, 2009
at 5:11 pm
Ya man, I never thought about it this way – but I guess you’re right. Thanks for sharing the thought!
By: Grist on April 8, 2009
at 8:32 am
i think ami seems more kuudere than tsundere >:
By: may on April 18, 2009
at 5:42 am
ami is awesomer
By: ami on June 9, 2009
at 2:03 pm
I don’t think ami is better than taiga. Taiga sure is cooler than ami. I hate how ami acts in front of other people showing them how “angel” she is (as if she was). I like Taiga being herself, she may be really bad to people but she’s honest to everyone which makes her more person than ami.Being yourself is better than being somebody else. And mind me, taiga’s cuter than ami. Ami somewhat resembles chidori of full metal panic,did anyone notice that??
By: Hirai17 on June 15, 2009
at 1:50 am